It is that time again.
The trees are going up in homes, chrismons and wreaths are going up in naves, department store caroling makes more sense than it did a week a go and parishioners are pressuring pastors to sing Christmas hymns during Advent.
It is time for Christmas. And what does that mean? That we celebrate the birth of Emmanuel and the promise of peace on earth by demonstrating the love and grace of God for every one of God's children? Yeah, right!
The secular season of Christmas (what the church calls Advent) is no longer a season of personal and communal preparation for the fulfilling of one of the greatest promises ever made. It is a season for doing the things God really intends; shopping, consuming, emotional pressure, spiritual neglect, hysteria and declarations about how "the liberals" are trying to steal Christmas.
It is time for the WAR ON CHRISTMAS! Make no mistake about it, this is war, people. Fox News even has a graphic and intro music. Only real wars get those. Across this great nation falsely believed to have been founded on Christian principles (slavery anyone?), liberals are infiltrating school boards and city councils to perpetuate their demonic plot to force all of us to say "Happy Holidays" rather than "Merry Christmas."
How dare they? Do they not realize that the salvation won in the life, death and resurrection in Christ depends on forcing four year old Jewish kids to sing "O, Little Town of Bethlehem?" Do they not understand that the nativity scene representing the romanticized scene at Christ's birth (yeah, Mary was showered and dressed that soon after labor) must be displayed in a classroom where Buddhist students are forced to contemplate the birth of Messiah even though there no messianic figure waiting to be born in Buddhism? Do they not realize that he coming of the kingdom of God depends fully on using the language of the Christian faith to make people feel uncomfortable and defensive?
Thankfully for the sake of the Kingdom and for we in the church, Field Marshall Bill "bats#!t" O'Riley and General Sarah "can't hold down a job for 24 consecutive months before I quit or get fired" Palin are on it. In an interview on Fox, Palin was taped saying that she "loves the commercialization" of Christmas because it spread the Christmas cheer so wide. Bill O'Riley was there to call out Macy's on daring to turn the laundry list of stuff that kids give the guy at the mall a "Holiday Wish List" rather than a "Christmas Wish List." How dare they fail to realize the spiritual importance of giving a list of demands to a stranger dressed in a red suit playing a modern adaptation of an ancient European pagan diety?
After spending some time this morning listening to these brave defenders of the faith-in-Christmas-stuff, I have decided that I am going to lay down my sword and surrender this particular war on Christmas. Liberals, you won this one.
I am laying down my sword and will no longer defend the rights of every person to be forced to sing the songs of my faith.
I am laying down my sword and will no longer defend the principle of consumerism as the purest form of faithfulness.
I am laying down my sword and will no longer defend the principle that my freedom of religion is not about personal devotional practice but about my God given right to make others feel ostracized and excluded because they do not share my faith.
I am laying down my sword and surrendering in this War on Christmas.
Now, perhaps, I can get back to that whole "season of expectation and anticipation of the miracle of the birth of God in the world" stuff. This year, I guess the birth of Christ will just have to suffice.
A Presbyterian pastor's thoughts about what it means to live a life of faith in the world today.
Wednesday, December 4, 2013
Thursday, August 1, 2013
Race and Confession
The verdict in the Trayvon Martin case on the heels of the
Supreme Court’s gutting of the Voting Rights Act has brought our shared
national legacy of racial division back to the foreground of our political
debates. Now, while the iron is hot, is the
time for theological conversation to strike on this enduring and complicated
issue.
Beyond the political rhetoric of the day, what can the church
say theologically about the legacy of racial division in American culture?
Besides simply saying “racism is sin” (which we should keep
saying), what can the church say on the topic of race to move our conversation
and our shared life forward?
As I began trying to formulate an answer to that question, I
found myself walking around and around answers and ideas but never getting far
beneath the surface. The first draft of
this post was little more than a string of platitudes and bumper-sticker slogans
on ending racism. Rev. Jim Forbes,
former pastor at Riverside Church in NYC, once referred to that sort of
theology as “hoop skirt theology,”- it covers everything but touches nothing.
Why, I began to wonder, am I not able to really go deep into
a theology of anti-racism? Why do I have
so much trouble thinking and writing beyond the platitudes? I ruminated on those questions for a couple
of weeks until it dawned on me. There is
a very simple reason why I have such difficulty talking deeply and formatively
on the subject of race.
I am a racist.
That is my confession.
I am a racist.
I fully realize how loaded that sentence is, but words are important and sometimes we have to call things like they are and not hedge our bets or soften our words. I define racism here not in terms of superiority of one group over another but as the persistent habit of seeing difference in other people before anything else.
I am not a KKK banner waving racist like David Duke or a
hate spewing racist like the pastor in Florida who keeps burning the Koran or
even a passive aggressive racist like half of the United States Congress. My racism is less cartoonish and frankly more
troubling. Now, I want to be clear at
this point and say that I do not set out to be a racist. In fact, I like to think of myself as being
pretty sensitive to the subject. I
cannot conceive of actively discriminating against another person for just
about any reason. Mine is not overt
hate-racism. Mine is that insidious form
of silent American racism that goes unnoticed and, like a lurking malignancy,
undiagnosed for years until it eats you away from the inside. It is the kind of racism that is unintentional but no less harmful. That is my sin. (Well one of them anyway)
We like to behave as though racism is just hate. To be sure, in its most insidious and often violent form it is. But racism is not reserved to the hatemongers and those who promote a politics of fear of the other. Sometimes it is silent. And silent racism in America is too easily and too often ignored.
This kind of American racism is not rooted in hate but in a
focus on the otherness of a person of a different race. For example, I do not dislike or disrespect
the President because he is an African-American. (In fact, I still have the bottle of wine my
mother and I used to toast his election in 2008 and I am proud that our nation
elected its first African-American President.)
But when I see him on television or in the newspaper, I see a black man
before I see a President. I see what is
different about him before I see anything else.
(I have to confess feeling a little indicted by the President when he
pointed to just that sort of racism in his impromptu speech in late July.)
The lingering liberal in me wants to say, “Well, difference
is good. Difference is diversity.” And I
suppose that is true on some level. It
is our differences that give definition and depth to our diversity and that is
a good thing. However, before diversity
can really be appreciated, we have to learn to define it in terms of our
commonality. We are diverse to be sure,
however we are diverse within a shared humanity.
Yet our shared humanity is rarely the first thing we
see. We see race, gender identity, age,
physical capability and all manner of physical differences before we see what it is we share- our humanity. Silent American racism (and its partners
sexism, homophobia, ageism and others) is the habitual and uncritical
willingness to see the difference in another person before seeing our shared
humanity if we see it at all.
In her wonderful book From
Disgust to Humanity, philosopher Martha Nussbaum calls American culture out
on our habitual pattern of creating boogeymen out of whole groups of people. Although Nussbaum focuses on GLBTQ
discrimination, her argument applies to the problem of silent racism as
well. Even silent racism creates
categories of people based on assumed differences that categorize those people
as “not like me.” We create an image that gives us permission to treat that
group and any member of it as other; as less than. (It
was fascinating how many times stories about Trayvon Martin that characterized
him as a young black male wearing a hoodie with pot in his system were followed
immediately with a picture of the President.) Nussbaum advocates for a “politics
of humanity” that resists this silent form of discrimination in favor of a
political culture rooted in our common humanity.
What Nussbaum advocates for in the political sphere, the
church must advocate in the theological.
Don’t we claim that we are ALL children of God? What greater witness can we make to the unity
we have in Christ than creating a culture that focuses first on our shared
humanity? Our shared created-ness in the
image of God? Before anything else, we are all children of
the Living God. Transcending any
possible division or category we might impose, we are all one in God’s family.
There is holiness in that message. There is holiness in proclaiming the love, hope
and unity of Jesus Christ. There is
holiness in declaring that before anything in the world that might seek to
divide us, we are united in the eyes of God; each of us wonderfully made and
precious in God’s sight. What a daring
and faithful message that would be in the world! What a bold church we would be if we only had
the courage to proclaim it!
Dr. King called Sunday morning worship the most segregated
hour in the week. It was true when he
said it nearly half a century ago and it is true today. Even the church is not immune to silent
racism. We have a long way to go to
become the people God desires us to be and a long way to go to become a
community of common humanity bearing witness to the world.
In the meantime, there is grace. Amazing grace for those of us who still have a
way to go; who still have some work to do in the journey from difference to
humanity.
Racism has been called “America’s original sin” and it is
going to take time for us to overcome it, however just because it is difficult
does not mean that we do not try.
They say the first step is admitting you have a problem.
No more silence; that is the first step.
Anyone ready to take it with me?
Monday, July 1, 2013
Wednesday, February 27, 2013
Abortion Politics and Genesis
The link below is to my sermon blog. It is another foray into the troubling waters of our public debate on abortion.
For All the Dinahs Today
For All the Dinahs Today
Friday, December 14, 2012
A Price too High
20 children are dead.
As the news of yet another mass shooting emerged today from
Connecticut, commentators, politicians and pundits began posing the questions
asked after events such as this. When is
it appropriate to debate gun violence?
How long after a tragedy do we need to wait before “politicizing” the
shootings? Essentially, they lead us in
a debate about the debate.
I have another question to pose.
When in the midst of
this ongoing orgy of gun violence will we as a society decide that too many
children are dying for the sake of a “right to bear arms?”
That is the question that faces us and it is a question that cannot wait. The old saying that there is "no time like the present" rings painfully true. We owe it to the next victims of gun violence to take this moment and ask, "is this worth it?"
Beyond all the grand and abstract language of liberty and
rights, there is a fundamental reality that is being ignored. 20 grade school children are dead because searing
pieces of metal fired from a gun tore through their bodies and robbed them of
their futures. Their deaths and their
families’ grief are not abstract. They are not merely a piece in a larger
conversation on guns and violence. Their
deaths are the price tag for preserving a culture of absolute liberty in gun
possession.
As with so many unspeakable tragedies, our first inclination
is to seek some measure of understanding.
We want to find out what in this young man’s life and spirit led him to
do this. We want to get to the bottom of
this event so we can put our minds at ease that this was somehow and unusual or
one-off event distinguished from any potential imitation.
Compounding the tragedy is how familiar it has become. Movie theaters, malls, places of worship and
now even elementary schools are not excused from the bloodshed of gun
violence. As the tragedy unfolds, we
share in a common sense of shock and sadness, let the media paint a picture of
the “lone gunman” that allows us to differentiate him from anyone else we may
encounter and finally, we get past it.
Still, 20 children are dead.
We as a culture must break this endless cycle of
tragedy-shock-blame-moving on. We must
draw a line in the sand and say, “no more.”
We, as a nation and as a church, must not let this moment pass us by.
Unfortunately both church and state are too often
silent. The vacuum of courage in our
political culture is not an excuse for the silence of the church. If we wait for Republicans to break free the
shackles of the NRA or the Democrats to find what is left of their courage on
this issue, we wait for Godot.
As disciples of Jesus Christ, the church has an obligation
to carry the message and the witness of Jesus Christ into the world. While there may be room for debate on some
parts of Jesus’ teachings on money or marriage or salvation, there can be no
debate about Jesus’ unflinching love and care for children.
We fail in our calling as Christians if we do not shout,
from every pulpit and pew, that this must end.
God is concerned more with the
care and nurture of the children of God than the preservation and exercise of
man-made political rights. If the price
we pay to end the cycle of violence that can and has led to the mass killing of
children is to give up the unfettered right to own and carry guns, then that is
the price we pay. Can true liberty be
built on the senseless sacrifice of children?
When Abraham took Isaac up onto the mountain, God stayed Abraham’s
hand demonstrating once and for all that the blood of a child is too high a
price to pay, even for the favor of God.
We, the church, must have the courage to stand up and stay the hand of
the culture and declare that nothing that is right, good or free can be bought
with the life of a child.
That is a cost that is simply too high.
Tuesday, October 23, 2012
Can Drone Warfare Be Just?
In the third presidential debate, President Obama and
Governor Romney found common ground on a few issues of foreign policy. One case in particular, the use of drone
attacks on terror suspects, stands out because Governor Romney stated simply
that he agrees with the President’s policy.
Some commentators have latched on to that to show how conservative the
President is on national security or how Governor Romney is more moderate than
some of his advisers Beneath it all,
the question is not one of liberal/moderate/conservative. It is a question of right or wrong.
Drone attacks are, by any reasonable measure, theologically
and morally wrong.
Drones, the unmanned aerial vehicle
or UAV, are a creation of the intelligence community and have become the front
line troops in the seemingly endless “war on terror.” Drones are designed to be
precise (though they have proven not to be), to be secure (though their
security has been called into serious question) and a means of winning the war
on terror (though there is no end in sight).
In truth, drones are the modern
equivalent of a societal prefrontal lobotomy about war. By removing the “human element” and replacing
it with non-emotional machines freed from the constraints of moral cognizance,
we have moved war from the realm of human tragedy to one of rationalized and
sterilized policy-making. It is far
easier to send a machine, more of which can easily be made, into war than it is
to risk the lives of our sons and daughters.
And to be fair, drones do limit the exposure and risk to our military
and civilian personnel. The trouble is
that as advanced and celebrated as they are, drones do not always work. In fact they often do not work. Some investigations claim that up to 25% of
drone related deaths are accidental.
Still, if they limit the exposure of
Americans and limit the extent of the war zones in Pakistan and Afghanistan,
don’t the advantages outweigh the drawbacks?
In other words, in the messy reality of war, aren’t drones at least a
little more moral?
If the only gauge of morality in war
was protection of “our side,” they certainly would be. However, under the principles of nearly 1600
years of Christian Just War theory, drones are, in fact, a less moral way of
waging war.
Just War theory can generally be
divided into two categories: jus ad
bellum (reasons to go to war) and jus
in bello (behavior in war). Since
the argument about going to war has long since been made irrelevant in the
present war, our attention is best directed to jus in bello. How, having
gone to war, must nations and people behave in war?
The general theory of jus ad bello lists five general
categories of behavior morally regulated by just war theory: distinction (distinguishing
civilians from combatants), proportionality (an act of war must not be
disproportionate to the precipitating act), military necessity (the act must be
necessary to defeat the enemy and end the conflict), fair treatment of
prisoners and the use of no means malum
in se (no means that are evil/immoral in and of themselves or the effects
of which cannot be controlled once used).[i]
The use of unmanned drones violates
at least three of these principles.
·
Distinction: The evidence is clear that drone attacks kill
civilians. Drones are neither limited
enough in their power nor precise enough in their guidance to ensure that only the
target is killed. While studies have
claimed that up to 25% of drones miss their targets and kill unintended
civilian populations, civilians are often the victims of successful drone
attacks. In 2011 a drone hit a tribal
council meeting in the Northwest Frontier Province of Pakistan. The four terrorist targets were killed, but
so were 38 others. Nearly 90% of those killed in the attack were not targets
but by-standers.
Another issue of
proportionality concerns the targets themselves. Often drone attacks target “terror suspects.”
They are executions carried out on suspects of terrorism rather than those
proven to have committed acts of terror.
There is no question that global terror is vastly different than a war
of opposing armies. The question for us
as a culture is whether or not that reality will so radically change the
metrics of our moral vision. We think
this person is a terrorist so we will kill him and his neighbors just in case
seems less than ideal as a moral foundation.
·
No Means Malum in Se: It is an overstatement
to say that drones are evil in and of themselves the way mass rape, child
conscription or the use of weapons of mass destruction are. Nonetheless, because they are free from the
moral difficulty of directly causing the death of another, drones are innately free
from moral inhibition and decision making.
Making war easier and less costly to wage has a coarsening effect on the
society fighting the war. Anything that
makes the commission of sin easier cannot, by definition, be anything but less
moral.
Do drone attacks make the “war on
terror” immoral? Is President Obama evil
for pursuing a policy of drone warfare?
Is Governor Romney evil for agreeing with him? Are the men and women who direct the drone
attacks evil for participating in such an immoral system? These and other questions that continue to
explore the morality of our current national security policies are (or at least
should be) of great concern to the church and people of faith.
Any war waged for any reason has dehumanizes and violates the most basic principle of Christian love. As 2000 years of history has taught us, though the community of Christ exists in the world the perfect peace of Christ does not yet. Just War theory has been an effective,
if imperfect, check on our propensity for war.
Restraint in war is one of the most enduring theological and
philosophical legacies of Christendom. If
we, as a community of faith, will not stand up for our own historic principles,
who is left?
There is no war that is free from
sin. There is only the degree to which
we submit to it. The larger question of
the morality of the “war on terror” will likely occupy the church for a
generation. The morality of drone
warfare should not.
[i] A
reasonable argument could be made that drones violate all five areas of Just
War theory concerning conduct in warfare.
Prisoners are mistreated in the fact that they are never taken prisoner
nor given the opportunity to surrender themselves. That drone attacks have been used since 2004
without great effect could reasonably argued as a violation of the principle of
military necessity. These are hardly
clear and reasonable arguments can be made on the other side of each. The same cannot be said for the other three
principles outlined above.
Saturday, October 20, 2012
Would You Baptize Exxon?
In 2010 the Supreme Court decided a case popularly called Citizens United. In a nutshell, it says that individuals, corporations and unions can spend unlimited amounts of money to elect or defeat a candidate for office as long as it is not coordinated by the candidate. (Much of the nonsense of this election season is brought to you by the Supreme Court of the United States.) Enough ink has been spilled on whether or not Citizens United was a good decision (I think not). I want to address an underlying issue raised by the ruling.
Part of the logic in Citizens United is that corporations are, for the purposes of speech in elections, persons and afforded the same protections of speech that an individual person is. Corporations are persons? What makes a person a person is a matter of deep philosophical debate. From a theological perspective, the answer is no easier. What makes a person a person?
When I was in seminary, this question came up in the context of a discussion about baptism. In my tradition we practice infant baptism rather than adult or "believer's" baptism. Underlying the theology of infant baptism is the notion that baptism is an act of faithfulness by the church in response to the faithfulness of God. The sacrament does not require any belief or comprehension on the part of the baptized as it does in "believer's" baptism. The question came up concerning whether or not it is appropriate to baptize an individual who cannot comprehend the sacrament. As someone who believes in infant baptism, the answer to that question is easy. For others it is not.
The court and much of the political community argue that corporations are persons. So my question is this, would you baptize Exxon?
Calling corporations people demeans what it is to be a person. People, homo sapiens, are created in the image of God. Whatever race, nationality, physical or mental disability or other characteristic or station in life, we are all created in the image of God. But is Wal-Mart or the AFL-CIO or even a non-profit like the United Way? Are these "persons" created in the image of God?
I realize that baptism is not a universal measuring stick to determine person-hood. You can be unbaptized and still be human (a child of God). It is, however, a helpful way of thinking about who and what might reasonably be included in the category of "person."
As a man of faith, I believe that calling corporations "persons" both misunderstands what it means to be human and demeans the person-hood of every one of God's children. You and I are made in the image of God, wonderfully made in fact and held in the heart of God since the beginning of time. I simply cannot believe that the same can be said of Best Buy or BP or even the Nature Conservancy.
I am not anti-corporation. I am against some of the abuses corporations commit and some of the dehumanizing policies of some corporations. On the whole, however, I have no moral objection to corporations as such. I just cannot get behind the idea that a corporation deserves the same consideration and rights as a child of God.
Whether Citizens United is good policy or good law is left to be decided.
That it is theologically troubling is clear.
Politics and Playgrounds
In separate posts that appeared on my Facebook news feed today friends shared links to articles that, in one case, called President Obama anti-Christian and in the other case called Governor Romney un-Christian. On one hand, I smiled a little in the realization that my friends are so diverse in their opinions. On the other, I found myself feeling frustrated that this sort of language is being thrown around in such personal terms.
I am not going to dignify the arguments in the articles with a reply. I do want to address this continual tendency to demonize political opponents with religious and personal epithets. We have, in our culture, lost the ability to separate opinion from character.
The vocabulary of our political debate has degraded to the level of an elementary school playground. You don't agree with me? Well then you are just a big poopy-head! It is all or nothing. It is reasonable to expect kids on the playground to lack nuance in disagreements, but these politicians and commentators are adults. Aren't we supposed to outgrow the reactionary absolutism of playground disagreements?
To be sure, there are policies from both Obama and Romney that I find theologically questionable. Earlier this year I posted an entry about what is popularly known as the "Ryan Budget,"the budget plan passed by the House of Representatives. I still believe that there are some serious theological problems with that budget's policies and the philosophy behind it. I do not, however, believe that makes the men and women who voted for it or wrote it un-Christian. I disagree with their policy positions and their philosophy. But I don't hate them and, in general, I do not doubt their sincerity of belief.
This is not the first time I have posted on this topic and I am sure that it will not be the last. We must find a way to separate opinions from character. I have friends who support political and policy ideas that I disagree with deeply. Does that mean we cannot be friends? Does it mean that they are somehow bad people? Does it mean that they are un-Christian or anti-Christian? NO! We simply disagree on some issues. It is not up to me to decide whether they are faithful Christians. It is not up to them to decide if I am.
I have a good friend whom I value greatly. We disagree on just about everything political. If I am for X, she is probably against it and if she is for Y, I am probably going to rail against it. We disagree but we don't hate one another. She is a wise, thoughtful and faithful Christian. We see the world differently. Or to put it in more biblical terms, we see through the glass dimly.
To refer to either the President or Mr. Romney as anti or un-Christian because of their beliefs is to set oneself up as the mind of God. Disagree. Disagree passionately. But do not mistake your own opinion as the final opinion of God. None of us has a monopoly on the truth.
I am not going to dignify the arguments in the articles with a reply. I do want to address this continual tendency to demonize political opponents with religious and personal epithets. We have, in our culture, lost the ability to separate opinion from character.
The vocabulary of our political debate has degraded to the level of an elementary school playground. You don't agree with me? Well then you are just a big poopy-head! It is all or nothing. It is reasonable to expect kids on the playground to lack nuance in disagreements, but these politicians and commentators are adults. Aren't we supposed to outgrow the reactionary absolutism of playground disagreements?
To be sure, there are policies from both Obama and Romney that I find theologically questionable. Earlier this year I posted an entry about what is popularly known as the "Ryan Budget,"the budget plan passed by the House of Representatives. I still believe that there are some serious theological problems with that budget's policies and the philosophy behind it. I do not, however, believe that makes the men and women who voted for it or wrote it un-Christian. I disagree with their policy positions and their philosophy. But I don't hate them and, in general, I do not doubt their sincerity of belief.
This is not the first time I have posted on this topic and I am sure that it will not be the last. We must find a way to separate opinions from character. I have friends who support political and policy ideas that I disagree with deeply. Does that mean we cannot be friends? Does it mean that they are somehow bad people? Does it mean that they are un-Christian or anti-Christian? NO! We simply disagree on some issues. It is not up to me to decide whether they are faithful Christians. It is not up to them to decide if I am.
I have a good friend whom I value greatly. We disagree on just about everything political. If I am for X, she is probably against it and if she is for Y, I am probably going to rail against it. We disagree but we don't hate one another. She is a wise, thoughtful and faithful Christian. We see the world differently. Or to put it in more biblical terms, we see through the glass dimly.
To refer to either the President or Mr. Romney as anti or un-Christian because of their beliefs is to set oneself up as the mind of God. Disagree. Disagree passionately. But do not mistake your own opinion as the final opinion of God. None of us has a monopoly on the truth.
Sunday, October 7, 2012
Toxic Preaching: Partisan Politics and the Pulpit
Today is "Pulpit Freedom Sunday." Organized a number of years ago, Pulpit Freedom Sunday is a day when pastors across the nation intentionally violate the Johnson Amendment making it against the law for non-profit organizations to endorse political candidates. Each election year, thousands of pastors participate and after preaching their offending sermons they mail them to the IRS.
To the unending frustration of the organizers of Pulpit Freedom Sunday, the IRS has yet to show any signs of caring. No prosecutions have taken place. No pastors clapped in irons. No churches seized for violation of some sacred code. These pastors are fighting a war against what they perceive as a government trying to silence them and the government won't fight back.
The non-existent war on religion in this country is the product of a half-century of political rhetoric aimed at preventing "Soviet-style" atheism in America. For decades the John Birch Society and others railed against the threat of atheism. As the Supreme Court continued to uphold the freedom of all Americans to worship as they choose and to untangle religion from government, a myth was born. The myth of the war against religion.
Today that war is fought on many fronts. There is the war on Christmas, the war on Sunday, the war on values and, in recent years, the war on "religious freedom." This new front has grown into the great "Western Front" of the imaginary war.
Religious freedom is the new buzzword for a particularly narrow segment of the Christian community's protest against some government actions. Generally speaking, what they perceive as "religious freedom" is in fact the freedom to impose their religion on the rest of us. Thus, Pulpit Freedom Sunday, the day when preachers declare what candidates are and are not faithful Christian choices.
The Johnson Amendment, passed at the height of the red scare as a protection measure for Lyndon Johnson's re-election campaign, states that non-profit organizations cannot endorse a particular candidate. The law was aimed at right-wing anti-communist organizations working against Johnson's re-election, however churches were swept up in the mix as well. It is against the law for a pastor to stand in the pulpit and say "vote for X."
My question is this. Who cares? Who cares if pastors cannot stand up in the pulpit and say "vote for X because it is the Christian thing to do?" What pastor in his or her right mind would want to do that in the first place?!
To be sure there are almost certainly pastors who serve congregations more politically homogeneous than my own. Not all congregations run the gamut from center-left to center-right and have Democrats, Republicans, Independents and none-of-the-aboves. Both of my congregations do. So in addition to being against the law, candidate electioneering is not such a good idea for me.
Even if I did serve a mostly like-minded congregation, though, I cannot imagine a circumstance when I would speak up for a candidate in my sermon. In the first place, I cannot imagine there being a candidate who is so vital to the interest of the community that their election rose to the level of parity with the word of God. Secondly, I cannot imagine preaching a sermon saying "vote for X because that is the Christian thing to do" and still being able to ask for the trust of a congregant who is voting for the other person.
As a pastor and preacher, my task is to stand in the pulpit and do my level best to tell the truth of the Gospel as I have come to know it. It is not my task to tell people how to live, that's Jesus' job. It is not my task to demand that people follow me; that is Jesus' job. It is not my task to declare who is and who is not righteous in the eyes of God; that is, well you get the point.
I am all for politics in the pulpit as long as "politics" means speaking about how we live together in the polis- the city. Electoral politics- the politics of personality and electioneering- have no place in the pulpit because they have no place in the vision of the word of God. When Jesus says "feed my sheep" he does not say "as long as it is a Democrat who gives them the food." When Jesus says "heal the sick" he does not say "as long as it is a Republican deciding how to do it."
The politics of the pulpit and the cross is not the politics of party and personality. It is the politics of the people of God living together in the City of Man, to use Augustine's language. The politics of the pulpit is about declaring that all God's children are deserving of food, shelter, clean water, freedom to worship and the basic dignity owed to every human being. The politics of the pulpit is about standing up to the forces in the world that would denigrate and degrade the children of God. The politics of the pulpit is beholden to no party or personality, it is beholden to God and God's word.
If we want our pulpits to be truly free, we bind them to the liberating word of God in Christ Jesus and the promise that is the City of God. Tethering the pulpit to the coattails of a political personality or even a political party does nothing but diminish its mission and anchor the pulpit to this world and the broken political machinations of the City of Man.
* UPDATE This entry was updated on 10/8/12 to correct a spelling error in the seventh paragraph.
To the unending frustration of the organizers of Pulpit Freedom Sunday, the IRS has yet to show any signs of caring. No prosecutions have taken place. No pastors clapped in irons. No churches seized for violation of some sacred code. These pastors are fighting a war against what they perceive as a government trying to silence them and the government won't fight back.
The non-existent war on religion in this country is the product of a half-century of political rhetoric aimed at preventing "Soviet-style" atheism in America. For decades the John Birch Society and others railed against the threat of atheism. As the Supreme Court continued to uphold the freedom of all Americans to worship as they choose and to untangle religion from government, a myth was born. The myth of the war against religion.
Today that war is fought on many fronts. There is the war on Christmas, the war on Sunday, the war on values and, in recent years, the war on "religious freedom." This new front has grown into the great "Western Front" of the imaginary war.
Religious freedom is the new buzzword for a particularly narrow segment of the Christian community's protest against some government actions. Generally speaking, what they perceive as "religious freedom" is in fact the freedom to impose their religion on the rest of us. Thus, Pulpit Freedom Sunday, the day when preachers declare what candidates are and are not faithful Christian choices.
The Johnson Amendment, passed at the height of the red scare as a protection measure for Lyndon Johnson's re-election campaign, states that non-profit organizations cannot endorse a particular candidate. The law was aimed at right-wing anti-communist organizations working against Johnson's re-election, however churches were swept up in the mix as well. It is against the law for a pastor to stand in the pulpit and say "vote for X."
My question is this. Who cares? Who cares if pastors cannot stand up in the pulpit and say "vote for X because it is the Christian thing to do?" What pastor in his or her right mind would want to do that in the first place?!
To be sure there are almost certainly pastors who serve congregations more politically homogeneous than my own. Not all congregations run the gamut from center-left to center-right and have Democrats, Republicans, Independents and none-of-the-aboves. Both of my congregations do. So in addition to being against the law, candidate electioneering is not such a good idea for me.
Even if I did serve a mostly like-minded congregation, though, I cannot imagine a circumstance when I would speak up for a candidate in my sermon. In the first place, I cannot imagine there being a candidate who is so vital to the interest of the community that their election rose to the level of parity with the word of God. Secondly, I cannot imagine preaching a sermon saying "vote for X because that is the Christian thing to do" and still being able to ask for the trust of a congregant who is voting for the other person.
As a pastor and preacher, my task is to stand in the pulpit and do my level best to tell the truth of the Gospel as I have come to know it. It is not my task to tell people how to live, that's Jesus' job. It is not my task to demand that people follow me; that is Jesus' job. It is not my task to declare who is and who is not righteous in the eyes of God; that is, well you get the point.
I am all for politics in the pulpit as long as "politics" means speaking about how we live together in the polis- the city. Electoral politics- the politics of personality and electioneering- have no place in the pulpit because they have no place in the vision of the word of God. When Jesus says "feed my sheep" he does not say "as long as it is a Democrat who gives them the food." When Jesus says "heal the sick" he does not say "as long as it is a Republican deciding how to do it."
The politics of the pulpit and the cross is not the politics of party and personality. It is the politics of the people of God living together in the City of Man, to use Augustine's language. The politics of the pulpit is about declaring that all God's children are deserving of food, shelter, clean water, freedom to worship and the basic dignity owed to every human being. The politics of the pulpit is about standing up to the forces in the world that would denigrate and degrade the children of God. The politics of the pulpit is beholden to no party or personality, it is beholden to God and God's word.
If we want our pulpits to be truly free, we bind them to the liberating word of God in Christ Jesus and the promise that is the City of God. Tethering the pulpit to the coattails of a political personality or even a political party does nothing but diminish its mission and anchor the pulpit to this world and the broken political machinations of the City of Man.
* UPDATE This entry was updated on 10/8/12 to correct a spelling error in the seventh paragraph.
Wednesday, September 12, 2012
Any Jackass Can Burn Down a Barn
When I was in high school, our communications teacher
attempted to introduce a film class. It
was the first time one had ever been offered in our school district and outside
of NYC or LA there were very few in any public schools. The result was a pretty free and open
environment for us to create the class.
We watched and critiqued great films, learned about some filming
techniques and, using the second hand VHS hand held camera the budget would
allow, we made our own films.
Compared to the footage available online of the now infamous
film “The Innocence of Muslims,” our 7 minute zero-dollar budget high school
production is “Citizen Kane” or Hitchcock’s “Rope.” If the rest of the film is even close to as
bad as the trailer footage, it ranks among the worst films ever made. (Think Ed Wood makes the “10 Commandments.”) Yet despite its lacking of any narrative or
artistic merit, this little film has sparked a tragic string of circumstances.
On Tuesday, protestors fueled by anger and lacking any sense
of moral restraint, attacked the United States embassy in Cairo breaching the
walls and desecrating the American flag.
In a related event, attacks on the United States consulate in Benghazi,
Lybia left the US Ambassador and two other embassy staff dead and several
others injured. These attacks certainly
did not materialize simply because the trailer for this film was released, but
there is little question that the film was one precipitating issue.
As someone who makes his living getting up in front of a
room (partially) full of people and who leans heavily on both an ethic of
professional freedom and the benefit of political freedom, I have an acute
appreciation and love for our nearly absolute freedom of speech. I like that I can get in the pulpit and
condemn my government without fear of reprisal and praise it without fear of
becoming its puppet. The freedom of
expression we enjoy as nation is perhaps our greatest blessing and the greatest
gift to the world that American constitutional democracy has given.
With that great freedom, however, comes even greater responsibility. As a pastor, I am also acutely aware that
just because I may say something does not always mean that I should
say it or that it is wise to say it.
That is a lesson lost on too many in our culture today.
The makers of this movie have every right to make a bad
film. A right they have availed themselves
of spectacularly. I for one make no
claim that what they have done should somehow be outlawed or banned. Free speech that is wise and helpful depends
on the freedom of speech that is insipid and stupid. Still, I think the filmmakers deserve a heavy
dose of criticism for choosing to make a film that has the obvious purpose of
making fun of and inciting anger from a group they do not like. The only reason the film has not been more
roundly condemned is that its subject matter involves a politically and
socially unpopular group- the Islamic community. A similar film that made fun of
African-Americans, women, Christians or Jews would not be tolerated. So taking advantage of the political
environment, the filmmakers offer their warped perspective on 1/5 of the world’s population.
The problem with this film is not that it is bad. It is not that it was not their right to make
it. The problem is that the film
represents one of the most reprehensible and craven characteristics of our
contemporary culture-“no one matters but me.”
According to this radical individualism and radical
libertarianism, my right to say whatever the hell I want trumps any consequence
of my words.
- My vitriol and bigotry leads a classmate to take his or her own life? Tough, free speech.
- My political rhetoric demeans a whole group of people and incites others to do violence to them? Tough, free speech.
- My film defames and ridicules another’s religion and risks reprisals in the midst of a tense and polarized global political culture? Tough, free speech.
Free speech is a blessing and a right of every person who
lives in this nation and, God willing, will one day be a basic human right
enjoyed by every one of God’s children.
That right is diminished and demeaned when it is used by fools in their
folly and when speech is not accompanied by wisdom and humanity. But wisdom and humanity take work.
Any jackass can burn down a barn. And the world never has a shortage of jackasses willing to do just that. It takes wisdom to build up rather than tear down. As with so many things, the role the church has to play in
this whole political mess is the enduring word of love and universal human
dignity. Central to the gospel of Jesus Christ is the dignity of all people. Not Christian people. Not American people. Not people I like or approve of but ALL people. ALL of God's children.
Free speech falls rapidly from
blessing to curse when it is used to diminish rather than celebrate the place
of a brother or sister as a child of God.
There is no excuse for the violence in Cairo or
Benghazi. There is also no excuse for
the abuse and misuse of a blessed right like the freedom to speak. Hopefully, “The Innocence of Muslims” will
fade rapidly from our collective memory.
With any luck, the lessons we learn from its narcissistic misuse
of a cherished right and its foolish attempt to dehumanize a whole religion will
not.
Tuesday, September 11, 2012
Moving the Pillar of Cloud and Smoke: A 9/11 Anniversary Sermon
It
Took Its Place Behind Them
Exodus 14:19-31
A Service of
Prayer and Remembrance
Commemorating
the 10th Anniversary of the September 11, 2011 Terrorist Attacks
A Joint Service
of Worship of
St. Paul Episcopal Church and First
Presbyterian Church of Batesville, AR
September 11,
2011
The Rev. Dr.
Robert Wm Lowry
Let me begin this evening by thanking Fr. John and
the congregation of St. Paul for the opportunity to be with you tonight and for
your hospitality. To paraphrase the
Psalmist, how good and now pleasant it is when friends dwell together in unity. This continues a good friendship between our
two congregations and that truly is a good and holy thing.
I take as my text this evening a portion
of the reading from Exodus we heard just moments ago.
The people of Israel are fleeing
from the hand of pharaoh through the Egyptian wilderness. The Lord commands Moses to raise up his staff
and extend his and over the waters of the sea so that they may part. He follows God’s command, and as the waters
part, in the words of the writer of Exodus,
“ the pillar of cloud moved from in
front of them and took its place behind them.”
Let us pray.
Almighty God, may the words of my
mouth and the meditations of all our hearts be pleasing to you our rock and our
redeemer. Should it please you to speak
through the words of this unworthy servant, then speak. And in this and all times, speak to us as
only you can, in the silence of our hearts.
Amen.
The
pillar of cloud moved from in front of them and took its place behind them.
Imagine
what it must have been like.
I
guess in truth, we don’t actually have to imagine. In his final monumental undertaking,
legendary filmmaker Cecil B. deMille paints a vivid, if not entirely accurate,
picture of the exodus from Egypt. Whenever
I read or hear this text, that image is my mental picture.
The
great cloud that looms above the people moves so that it is stationed firmly
between the people of Charlton Heston and Yul Brenner’s army. The billowing smoke, the occasional glimpses
of fire, the flashing lightening all combine to make Hollywood magic.
At
the moment these events were unfolding for the people of Israel, I doubt it was
quite the popcorn moment. I imagine it what
must have been an awesome almost terrifying sight.
In
that moment, the pillar of fire and smoke that led them through the Egyptian
desert gives way to the corridor of dry land bordered by the two great walls of
water inviting the people to cross the sea and enter into the Promised Land.
It
is an epic, emotional, dramatic scene.
In all it’s 1950’s technicolory Hollywood majesty, the climactic scene
of one of the climactic movies of the last century invites us to know what it
was to stand there that day in the shadow of the pillar of cloud and smoke and
fire.
In
the end of course, the people escape, Pharoah’s army is engulfed by the sea,
God’s promise is fulfilled and all Pharoah can do… is go home to Anne Baxter.
The
story of the people of Israel crossing from slavery in Egypt into the freedom
of God’s Promised Land is one of the great narratives in human history and one
of the pivotal ones in the greater story of the people of God. When the people first set foot on the bed of
the sea, a new day dawned.
And
the turning point was when the pillar of cloud moved from in front of them and
took its place behind them.
I
am hardly the first preacher to draw a parallel between the pillar of cloud in
the book of Exodus and the pillar of fire and smoke that erupted on lower
Manhattan a decade ago this morning.
What
began as a beautiful autumn morning with a big blue sky and perfect fall
weather quickly became a picture of darkness and destruction and death. The misguided and misdirected anger and hate
of 18 young men would ignite a fire that would burn even when the flames were
put down and the rubble carted off.
I
recalled in my sermon this morning the landing
in Newark Airport on September 13 the day air traffic resumed. When the airplane banked over northern New
Jersey and began to fly down the Hudson toward Newark’s runway, I had a clear
view of lower Manhattan out my window. I
remember the skyline of lower Manhattan with a void where two great towers of
concrete and steel had stood just three days before. I remember the plumes of smoke and steam
that, though of a lesser magnitude than they had been days before, still
billowed into the sky like the exhalations of some great beast dwelling beneath
the streets and struggling to be let loose on the world.
That
pillar of fire and smoke would remain firmly fixed in our minds eye long after
it disappeared from our view. I would
wager to say that for many of us it would be easy to conjure up a vision of it
right now.
It
remains fixed before us defining everything else in our line of sight. It has become the measuring stick by which
world events are now measured.
It
is almost as if that day was the restarting point of time. Pre-9/11 and post-9/11 are our new cultural
BC and AD.
Late
last week, a friend who is a stringer for NPR called to interview me for a
piece he was working on that was broadcast on Saturday. I’m afraid I wasn’t much help to his
story. He and several other reporters
around the country were interviewing people about what they were doing on
September 10, 2001. When he asked me, I
searched my memory trying to think of what it might have been. In the end, all I could remember was that it
was a sunny Monday in Shreveport and I took the dog for a walk down by the river
before substitute coaching pee-wee football in the afternoon.
That
was it.
Nothing
else stands out.
It
was just a plain old Monday.
Had
he asked me about the next day, I could give him moment by moment details. It is still vivid and at times feels ever
present. As a colleague commented to me
the other day, it is almost as if one September day has lasted for ten years.
I
wonder if perhaps tonight, with ten years between those tragic events and this Lord’s
Day, it might not be time to let it be a new day. Perhaps it is time that the pillar of cloud
moves from in front of us and takes its place behind us.
Like
most things, that is easier said than done.
When
the Israelites stood on the banks of the Red Sea and Moses hurried them along
to journey across to the Promised Land, there must have been at least a moment
when the people thought better of that suggestion. There must have been a moment when someone
said, “you know that pillar of cloud back there got us this far, maybe we need
to stick with it. Maybe we should keep
it out front.”
With
the unknown horizon across the sea in front of them, I imagine that it was
tempting to turn around, put their backs to the unknown and set their eyes and
expectations on the familiar; the pillar of cloud that had led them thus far.
Given
the option between the known and the unknown, most of us will choose the former
every time.
The
problem with sticking with the familiar for the Israelites was that the pillar
had moved. It was no longer in front of
them pointing the way to freedom and the Promised Land. Now it was behind them. To turn and face it now meant to turn away
from freedom and direct themselves, once again, toward Egypt; toward Pharaoh;
toward captivity.
The
pillar of cloud moved from in front of them and took its place behind them.
None of us will forget the events of that
September morning.
Nor
should we. It will rightly remain a part
of our collective memory and shade our perspective of the world for generations
to come.
The
image of that pillar of fire and smoke that came from lower Manhattan, from the
outer ring of the Pentagon and from a lonely field in rural Pennsylvania will
remain ever present in the narrative of our nation and our world.
Nonetheless,
it is, perhaps, time that we posed a question to ourselves. Where does that pillar of fire and smoke
belong? Shall it remain in front of us,
continuing to give direction and shape to our lives; shall that pillar of fire
and smoke remain our true north or shall it take its place behind us? Not as a forgotten chapter but as a reminder
of where we have been and where, in the mercy and grace of God, we hope to
never return.
Today
we remember the lives not only of the nearly 3000 who lost their lives on
September 11, 2001, but also the more than 4000 who, since that day lost their
lives in Iraq and the more than 1800 who lost their lives in Afghanistan, 80 as
recently as this morning, along with countless civilians caught in the middle
of a war of other’s making.
As
we look back in mourning on those who are lost, we must have the courage to
also look forward in hope to the tomorrow that God has promised. If we linger too long on the past, if we
allow our world to be measured not by the promise of God’s tomorrow but by
yesterday’s tragedies, we fail to do honor to their memories by wasting the
future of which they have been deprived.
If
we do indeed have that courage to look into the horizon of tomorrow, we will
never forget what came before nor will we enslave ourselves to it as we cross
over into God’s promise.
The
pillar of cloud moved from in front of them and took its place behind
them.
May
it be so for us and for our world.
Sola
Deo Gloria! To God alone be the
Glory. Amen.
Monday, September 3, 2012
Child of God, Child of God, Child of God
As we enter the fools carnival that masquerades as presidential politics in this country, the rhetoric about parties, personalities and platforms (and other things that do not start with "p") will heat up beyond the usual levels. The scorched earth politics of 21st century America will leave few unscathed. As things progress, it gets tempting for people of deep belief and passion to join in the mud and word slinging. When those moments come and that temptation is upon us, I hope that we can all take a moment and do one thing. Look across the political landscape at your "target" and remember that that person (or that whole group of people) is a child of God.
One of the lessons I have learned in my ministry is to respond in frustration or anger only after looking at the person with whom I am angry and saying to myself a few times "child of God, child of God, child of God." It helps to put things into perspective. I wish I could say that it has saved me from ever uttering words I would later regret. Unfortunately, this little trick is not quite that effective. But it does remind me that the object of my anger or frustration is also the object of the love and care of God.
Our political vocabulary has been hijacked by the vocabulary of division. The other side of the aisle has become the enemy of all that is good and right. It is not enough to oppose a candidate, you have to hate him or despise her in order to show your own loyalty to party and country. In a culture that defines those with whom we disagree as quite nearly less than human, it is no wonder that we use the sort of language that we use.
As a Christian, I am called to remember that we are all part of the family of God. In our vocabulary of faith, we are brothers and sisters united by God's love for us. So to demean or dehumanize someone with whom I have a political disagreement is to demean or dehumanize my brother or sister in Christ.
There are certainly times when we need to speak up against a position a particular person takes or take a stand against a policy or ideal that tends to diminish or dehumanize a person or group of people. Those prophetic moments are important to our growth as a community striving for greater and wider justice for all. But when we do that, perhaps we can do it without casting aspersions on the motives of our political opponents. It is one thing to oppose abortion, another to call those who support choice "baby-killers." It is one thing to oppose cuts in social programs , another to call those who propose those cuts "uncaring" or "unChristian."
There are very real issues and very real problems that we need to address as a nation in this election year. Perhaps we need to remind ourselves that disagreement on policy is not the same as disqualification from the human race. Perhaps we need to remember that reasonable people can and do disagree and that even in the midst of our passionate disagreements, we need to disagree reasonably.
When in doubt, just remember...child of God, child of God, child of God.
One of the lessons I have learned in my ministry is to respond in frustration or anger only after looking at the person with whom I am angry and saying to myself a few times "child of God, child of God, child of God." It helps to put things into perspective. I wish I could say that it has saved me from ever uttering words I would later regret. Unfortunately, this little trick is not quite that effective. But it does remind me that the object of my anger or frustration is also the object of the love and care of God.
Our political vocabulary has been hijacked by the vocabulary of division. The other side of the aisle has become the enemy of all that is good and right. It is not enough to oppose a candidate, you have to hate him or despise her in order to show your own loyalty to party and country. In a culture that defines those with whom we disagree as quite nearly less than human, it is no wonder that we use the sort of language that we use.
As a Christian, I am called to remember that we are all part of the family of God. In our vocabulary of faith, we are brothers and sisters united by God's love for us. So to demean or dehumanize someone with whom I have a political disagreement is to demean or dehumanize my brother or sister in Christ.
There are certainly times when we need to speak up against a position a particular person takes or take a stand against a policy or ideal that tends to diminish or dehumanize a person or group of people. Those prophetic moments are important to our growth as a community striving for greater and wider justice for all. But when we do that, perhaps we can do it without casting aspersions on the motives of our political opponents. It is one thing to oppose abortion, another to call those who support choice "baby-killers." It is one thing to oppose cuts in social programs , another to call those who propose those cuts "uncaring" or "unChristian."
There are very real issues and very real problems that we need to address as a nation in this election year. Perhaps we need to remind ourselves that disagreement on policy is not the same as disqualification from the human race. Perhaps we need to remember that reasonable people can and do disagree and that even in the midst of our passionate disagreements, we need to disagree reasonably.
When in doubt, just remember...child of God, child of God, child of God.
Wednesday, August 22, 2012
Let's Stop the Linguistic Gymnastics: Rape is Rape
This summary is not available. Please
click here to view the post.
Tuesday, July 24, 2012
The Real Trouble with Mormon Jokes
One of the
more popular punch lines in religious jokes is the Mormon’s “magic underwear.” From stand-up comedy to South Park to jokes
between friends, the undergarments of Mormon adults make an easy target for
humor. I have to confess to having made
a few less than generous remarks about them, much to my personal shame. Mormons are one of the few groups it is still
acceptable to make fun of in public and that is a matter of real shame.
The “magic
underwear” is neither magic nor underwear.
Referred to as “the garments,” the two pieces resembling an undershirt
and a pair of extra-long boxer briefs are a symbol for devout Mormons of their
inclusion in a community. One
commentator compared it to a yarmulke or nun’s habit. The garment marks a Mormon’s inclusion in the
community following the endowment ceremony in the temple.
One day Mormons
too will be off limits to “acceptable” humor. For my part, whenever I feel like
making a “magic underwear” crack, I will ask myself if I would make the same
crack about a yarmulke. I cannot think
of a circumstance when I would.
Beyond the
purely insensitive and tasteless nature of “Mormon jokes,” there is a larger
theological question lingering. What is
it about us that needs to have a ready butt for jokes? Since my childhood, I remember when it was
considered socially acceptable to make jokes about African-Americans, Jews,
GLBTQ people and, yes, Mormons in polite company. In hindsight, I wonder just how polite that
company could possibly have been. The question
maintains; what is it about us that needs to have a ready butt for jokes?
Let me start
by acknowledging that not everyone makes off color jokes. This is not meant to point fingers at any
particular person or people. Rather it
is an observation about how we work as a culture. There seems to be an unwritten rule that at
least one group needs to be available to be the punch line at all times; some
group has to be an outlier.
It is
important to belong to some community.
Even people who disdain community belong to the community of
disdain. But unless the community is
popular, powerful or influential enough not to give a damn, there is an assumed
social convention that we keep our membership in those communities to ourselves. In a way, the garments of the Mormon tradition
respect that convention. They are worn
under the clothes and do not come with a nametag that says, “I have on my
endowment garments under my clothes.”
They are a very personal expression of devotion. But their ubiquity makes them an assumed part
of every Mormon adult’s life and an easy target for mockery.
There is a
measure of “chicken and egg” to this pattern of humor at the expense of others
as well. Is this a symptom of our
culture or is our culture a symptom of this tendency?
Whatever the answer to that question, one thing is certain. Humor at the expense of a community of our neighbors coarsens and diminshes us as a culture.
There is no
easy answer. Few things that matter have
one. But it is a question worth asking
ourselves when we offer up a supercilious joke or make off the cuff remarks at
the expense of a group or community.
Monday, July 23, 2012
A Radically Moderate Stance on Guns
As I left church on Sunday morning, I was asked a question
that I am still unable to fully answer.
I was asked, “If you had been in that movie theatre [Aurora, CO] and you
had a firearm [he mentioned a particular model that I do not recall], would you
have hesitated to pull it and shoot that guy?”
When he asked the question, I gave him the only answer I could think of
at the moment, “I don’t know.”
It is a tough question for a number of reasons. Mostly, I just have trouble imagining what
would be going through my mind at that moment.
My ego wants to think that I would heroically help people get out of the
theatre and to safety all the while keeping an eye on the gunman and planning
how to disarm him ala the movies. I know
I am not the only person who had that thought.
It is a difficult question to answer because it assumes a hypothetical
that would never take place. There is no
circumstance that would convince me to carry a firearm into a crowded theatre
so I would never be face with the decision in the first place.
After some reflection on the question, I think I have put my
finger on at least part of why it is so tough to answer. I do not accept the premise that what
happened is somehow normal or expected. That
seems to be an undercurrent of many comments on this shooting. People wonder why no one fired back as though
midnight at the movies is the same thing as high noon in Tombstone. Things that we anticipate happening in the
world are easy to hypothesize about, but this is way outside those bounds. The question I think we should be asking is
not what I would do in this foregone reality, but what we as a society should
be doing to prevent this sort of thing from happening.
Part of the reason we avoid that last question is that it
takes us into some territory that is uncomfortable. But if we are going to talk about what
happened in Aurora, CO we have to talk about guns and if we talk about guns we
have to talk about how we can curtail the problem of proliferation of guns to
people who have no business having them.
This is the point that most of my pro-gun friends tune me
out. But please a bear with me. This is not a question of pro-gun or
anti-gun. The extremes on both ends of
the political spectrum have worked to turn this into a zero-sum conversation in
order to stop any sort of compromise from happening. They have hijacked an important political and
religious issue. And make no mistake
about it, gun-control is a religious matter (more on that below).
Now those on the “pro-gun”side argue that any limitations on
gun ownership are unconstitutional and lead us down a slippery slope toward
banning all fire arms. Reasonable gun
control is neither of these things. The
Supreme Court decision that interpreted the 2nd Amendment to mean
that individuals have the right to possess just about any weapon they choose
required a Cirque du Soliel worthy contortions of language and logic. It is highly doubtful that the Founders had
in mind an individual owning a small arsenal of automatic and semi-automatic
weapons designed for one purpose only, to kill another human being. The slippery slope argument does not hold
water either. There are almost as many
handguns in this country as there are people.
The FBI says there are over 200 million privately owned handguns in this
country. Count in the illegal and unregistered
ones and there is one gun for nearly every man, woman and child. The idea that any gun control is going to
lead us down the slippery slope to banning all guns makes about as much sense
as thinking that we could ban asphalt.
Nothing this deeply entrenched in our culture is going anywhere.
Those on the “anti-gun” side offer no better arguments. They claim that guns must be banned in order to
prevent crime and to bring the United States into line with other developed
countries. The crime prevention argument
does not hold water. Availability of
guns is not the root cause of crime. To
fight crime we need to deal with education, health care, housing and poverty
issues that are shown to be at the root of much crime. From a theological perspective, crime is a
manifestation of human sinfulness. We
were sinners with spears and swords just as we are with guns and assault
weapons. As for the cultural argument,
it fails to realize that the US is a different society than European
countries. Guns and gun ownership are in
our cultural DNA whether we like it or not.
When some European countries banned handguns, there was not much there
to ban. As noted above, in the US
banning handguns, let alone all guns, would be a practical impossibility.
So what do we do? How
do we address this question from a practical and theological perspective?
Practically, we need to take a step back from the zero-sum
battle lines that have been drawn on this issue and recognize that unfettered
access to firearms is unwise and ridding them from the nation forever
impractical.
The solution to this problem is found not in a purely policy
focused conversation but one of public morality. What sort of society are we hoping to
create? What values do we want to be
reflected in our laws? On the issue of
guns, these questions are more important than usual because they offer us the
chance to reclaim an important national debate and take it back from the
lunatic fringe.
So what values do we want to be reflected in our gun laws?
From a constitutional perspective, there is the issue of the
right to “keep and bear arms.” The 2nd
Amendment is not going anywhere so we need to take it seriously.
From a social perspective, we want a society in which
individual can be (not merely feel but actually be) secure that their life and
liberty will not be violated.
From a moral perspective, we need a society that puts a
premium on human life over personal liberty.
Surely we can find some common ground there? A responsible person who wants to own a
firearm should be able to do so. But is
liberty really threatened by a thorough background check? Or a firearms safety course? Or even a limit on how many firearms one
person owns?
Put another way, was making guns easy to buy with no
questions asked worth the price that was paid last week in that movie
theatre? If steps could be taken to keep
guns out of the hands of an unbalanced person, is there any legitimate reason
for not doing that?
I believe that the personal liberty we enjoy as citizens is
important. It is important as a means of
keeping tyranny at bay. It is important
as a means of showing political respect to the individual. It is important for creating space in society
for differing opinions and perspectives to flourish and thrive side by
side. So protecting liberty is a valid
and important thing. But it is not the
only thing. Protecting society as a
whole is vitally important. And when we
balance those two, individual liberty and safety for society, we have to
remember that firearms present a very different issue than speech or press or
other matters of constitutional importance.
When someone hurls hateful words, they do not draw blood. A person abusing his or her right to free speech
does not usually leave a trail of bodies in their wake. The right to keep and bear arms does. Guns are not like speech. The person taking advantage of free speech
may make me mad, but the person abusing his right to bear arms may leave me
dead.
As a citizen, I believe that individual liberty must be
preserved whenever possible but not at the expense of the safety of others.
As a Christian, I don’t give much of a damn about
liberty. It is not a theological
issue. Personally, I would like to see
all guns gone from our culture. There is
no legitimate Christian value that is forwarded by the owning much less the
using of a firearm. Jesus taught peace
and respect for life as the central principles of our life in the world and
love of God as the central principle of our life in whole. There is no legitimate theological argument
to be made for the liberty to carry a weapon designed to kill another human
being. At the same time I cannot buy
into the argument that the ownership of a firearm of any kind is in and of
itself a non-Christian act.
Please don’t get me wrong, I do not buy into the NRA myth
that “guns don’t kill people, people do.”
Yes, that is true but it is also true that the gun makes it much easier
for that person to kill. So let’s not
let the guns off the hook quite so easily.
Do I think the world would be better without guns? Yes, I do.
But I also think it would be better without many things that are not
going anywhere anytime soon. And if we
can’t get rid of them, we can at least curtail their misuse.
Part of living into that Christian life is using the
intelligence and creativity that God has given us to find ways to make this
world a little bit better, a little bit safer and a little bit more attuned to
his message of grace and love. Surely we
have an obligation to put those tools to work on such a major issue as
this.
The debate over guns is yet another place where our society
has accepted the zero-sum either/or duality of the radical extremes on the left
and right. So it is up to we who
inhabit the middle to put our heads together and find solutions to our common
problems that are both practical and faithful to our calling as brothers and
sisters in the world.
I am convinced that there is a solution to this long
standing issue and we have an obligation to work toward a system in which
honest and law abiding people can exercise their rights while still allowing
the system to protect the innocent.
Would stricter gun laws have prevented this shooting? I don’t know.
I am convinced, though, that there is a place between the extremes where
efforts to prevent tragedies such as this and preserving the liberty of
individuals who feel the need to own guns can co-exist.
Nonetheless, I am still not sure how to answer the question
posed to me on Sunday.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)